Pickbench
Contact

Car rental companies

Which brand 5 AI models pick, with intervals.

47 scenariosBetaBrand names only

Fast panel · Panel, equal weight

  • anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 @ claude-haiku-5.5 via OpenRouter (20%)
  • openai/gpt-6-luna @ gpt-6-luna via OpenRouter (20%)
  • google/gemini-4-argon @ gemini-4-argon via OpenRouter (20%)
  • mistralai/mistral-large-4-0 @ mistral-large-4-0 via OpenRouter (20%)
  • deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash @ deepseek-v4.1-flash via OpenRouter (20%)

Too closeNo single favourite: Enterprise Rent-A-Car, Hertz, and National Car Rental share the top tier for these 5 API models.

Choice share · 95% interval
0255075100

Tier 1

  1. Enterprise Rent-A-Car77%95% interval 65–87%plausible rank 1–3
  2. National Car Rental55%95% interval 44–66%plausible rank 1–6
  3. Hertz33%95% interval 22–45%plausible rank 1–8

Tier 2

  1. Alamo Rent A Car30%95% interval 20–41%plausible rank 2–7
  2. Avis28%95% interval 19–38%plausible rank 2–8
  3. Budget Rent a Car16%95% interval 8–27%plausible rank 2–10
  4. Thrifty Car Rental5%95% interval 1–13%plausible rank 3–10

Tier 3

  1. Dollar Rent A Car4%95% interval 0–12%plausible rank 4–10
  2. Sixt3%95% interval 0–9%plausible rank 6–10
  3. Fox Rent A Car2%95% interval 0–11%plausible rank 6–10
How to read this
  • Choice share: how often models pick a brand when it appears in a shortlist of 4. Chance is 25%, the dashed line.
  • The band is the 95% interval; the bright tick is the estimate. Overlapping bands are not a strict order.
  • Tiers are published: a tier groups brands not distinguishable from that tier's leader. Same tier does not mean equal.
  • Rank shows the plausible rank range, not a strict place.
  • Drag across the chart to probe a share and see which intervals contain it.
  • Brand names only: the models saw each option as a brand name, with no product facts, and answered from their own knowledge.
  • Fast panel: the fast or small current models of each vendor, not the full flagship panel.
  • Beta: intervals are not yet small-sample calibrated.
  • Each page shows the latest edition. Dates are in the downloadable JSON.

Panel and conditions

Each edition puts the brands of the category to a panel of AI models, called through their APIs, in randomized shortlists of 4 (chance is 25%). Each option was a brand name only, with no product facts, prices or any commercial data, so a brand's share measures which brand the models recommend from their own knowledge for the shopper needs of the scenarios. Shares come with 95% intervals; tiers and rank intervals are simultaneous at the same level.

  • anthropic/claude-haiku-5.5 @ claude-haiku-5.5 via OpenRouter (20%)
  • openai/gpt-6-luna @ gpt-6-luna via OpenRouter (20%)
  • google/gemini-4-argon @ gemini-4-argon via OpenRouter (20%)
  • mistralai/mistral-large-4-0 @ mistral-large-4-0 via OpenRouter (20%)
  • deepseek/deepseek-v4.1-flash @ deepseek-v4.1-flash via OpenRouter (20%)

Conditions: closed-book API calls via OpenRouter (pinned providers); web search, grounding, tools and retrieval off; forced choice; 2 paraphrases per scenario in English.

Methodology: ACM-1.0-chart-draft (draft rules for movement, significance and events, awaiting review).

All boards